The easiest, tastiest Instant Pot Mac and Cheese you’ll ever meet. Creamy, delicious, and crazy good, homemade Mac and Cheese doesn’t get any EASIER or BETTER than this. On the table in 20 minutes!
Meet my guilty pleasure- Instant Pot Mac and Cheese. I have a confession -every once in a while I get a hankering for Mac and Cheese, you know, the kind that comes in a box. As a kid, I can tell you the number of times my parents made this for me. ZERO!
It was something my immigrant parents NEVER made and you know how it goes, when you are not allowed to have something, you just end up wanting it more! I remember sneaking over to my neighbor’s house and having it there. 😉
Fast forward. My friend Cheri is a mom of three young boys and this is one of her “go-to” quick and easy meals, one that her boys love. More times than I’d like to admit, I’ve found myself stealing spoonfuls of it out of her Instant Pot as I walk by, just too delicious to resist. It brings me back to those childhood days of sneaking over to my neighbors! Creamy and flavorful, Macaroni and Cheese is the ultimate comfort food!
Perhaps this pasta recipe doesn’t seem healthy on the surface, but “healthy” is quite relative, isn’t it? It’s healthier than coming out of a box with lots of ingredients that look unfamiliar.
Anyways, That’s how I like to justify it. 😉
And of course, you could top it with something nutritious – steamed broccoli, kale, edamame, etc. But at this point in my inner debate, I default to, why bother, and serve it up with Everything Spice (my favorite!) and chili flakes.
Do as you like. 😉
Ingredients in Instant Pot Mac and Cheese
I can already feel you looking at that evaporated milk… and I sense a little judgment. 😉 YES, there are other cream/milk options you can absolutely use- please feel free- but the evaporated milk really does seem to give this the BEST and creamiest texture here. Milk or cream seems to create a grainier texture.
- shallot– adds so much depth! ( or if in a hurry, skip it)
- macaroni- or other pasta
- butter and olive oil– or sub vegan butter, or other oil
- evaporated milk (truly gives the BEST texture) try this organic brand of evaporated milk
- dijon mustard (or mustard powder)- gives mac and cheese a delicious “tang”.
- grated cheddar cheese (or meltable vegan cheddar)
- pepper jack cheese (or sub gruyere, meltable vegan jack cheese )
- Optional additions: Kale, broccoli, edamame, Everything Bagel Spice, Allepo Chili flakes
How to make Instant Pot Macaroni and Cheese
Step one
Set the instant pot to the “saute” function and sauté the shallot in the olive oil, until tender and fragrant.
Step two
Add the water, macaroni and salt, and set the Instant Pot to pressure cook on high for 4 minutes. Manually release.
Step three
Stir in the butter and mustard. Don’t worry if the noodles seem a bit watery at first.
Step four
Stir in the evaporated milk.
Step five
Add two kinds of cheeses ( for the best flavor and texture).
Here I’ve used cheddar and pepper jack. 
Give a good stir.
And that is it!
As the Mac and Cheese sits in the instant pot (on warm) it will thicken a bit.
A creamy bowl of deliciousness.
And topped with the Everything Spice- it’s insanely good!
It’s a low-maintenance recipe to have at a gathering that all kids love, but I’m sure you’ll see a few grown-ups sneaking in for a helping or two at the end of the night.
Can this be made Vegan?
I haven’t tried, but I believe it could be adapted easily. Use vegan butter, and vegan cream, and meltable vegan cheese. Perhaps a sprinkle of nutritional yeast.
Or try this recipe for VEGAN MAC AND CHEESE!
Ways to elevate Instant pot Mac and Cheese
- Use good quality cheese, organic is nice.
- Top with vegan cheesy sprinkle or Everything Bagel spice, or chili flakes.
- Top with Crispy Shallots
- Top with Sauteed Mushrooms, steamed broccoli, or stir in kale or spinach or edamame.
Enjoy the Instant Pot Mac and Cheese, let us know what you think in the comments below.
xoxoxo
More recipes you may like:
- Kimchi Chili Mac and Cheese
- Truffle Mac and Cheese
- Our 25 Best Instant Pot Recipes
- Creamy Vegan Mac and Cheese
- Instant Pot Mushroom Stroganoff
- Easy Healthy Veggie-Driven Pasta Recipes! (Vegan-adaptable)
Instant Pot Mac and Cheese
- Prep Time: 5
- Cook Time: 10
- Total Time: 15 minutes
- Yield: 6-8
- Category: instant pot, main, vegetarian, pasta
- Method: instant pot, pressure cooker
- Cuisine: american
- Diet: Vegetarian
Description
Instant Pot Mac and Cheese- creamy, delicious and crazy good, homemade Mac and cheese doesn’t get any easier than this!
Ingredients
- 1 tablespoon olive oil
- 1 shallot, finely chopped
- 4 cups water
- 2 1/2 – 3 teaspoons salt (I prefer 3)
- 16 ounces elbow macaroni
- 2 tablespoons butter
- 12 ounce canned evaporated milk
- 1/2–1 teaspoon dijon mustard (or mustard powder)
- 2 1/2 cups grated cheddar cheese
- 1 cup grated pepper jack cheese (or sub mozzarella, gruyere, or other melty cheese)
- To “adultify” the Mac & Cheese, garnish with Everything Bagel Spice and Chili flakes
Instructions
- Set Instant Pot to Saute function.
- Add olive oil and shallot and saute until sizzling and fragrant, about 2 minutes. Add water, salt and macaroni and give a good stir. Set Instant Pot to pressure cook, on high, for 4 minutes. Manually release.
- Stir the pasta, there will be a little water, this is OK. Stir in the butter, evaporated milk, and mustard. Stir in the cheese a cup at a time, until fully melted and incorporated. Taste, add more mustard for extra tanginess.
- As the macaroni and cheese sits, it will thicken up beautifully.
- Feel free to garnish with Everything Bagel Spice, Chili flakes, or Sriracha.
Notes
Using two different types of cheese here really elevates.
If in a hurry, you can skip the sauteed shallot in the beginning, and sub a teaspoon of onion powder or garlic powder.
Nutrition
- Serving Size:
- Calories: 493
- Sugar: 4.7 g
- Sodium: 1246.7 mg
- Fat: 22.4 g
- Saturated Fat: 12.1 g
- Carbohydrates: 50.4 g
- Fiber: 1.9 g
- Protein: 21.8 g
- Cholesterol: 55.2 mg
Okay this was hands down the best Mac n cheese I’ve ever made. I used 2 cups medium cheddar, 1 cup Colby jack, 1/4 cup shredded Parmesan and 2 tbsp cream cheese. I honestly think that was the magic combo. And I used 1/4 cup minced onion and two cloves of garlic instead of the shallot. I also used rigatoni because that’s what I had but had to cook it a minute longer. It feels more simply in the instant pot but I’m sure you could do this on the stove top fine. It was so good! Definitely our go to Mac n cheese now.
Great to hear Amanda! Thanks for leaving a review and rating!
ADORE this recipe. Made it stovetop and put under the broiler. Perfect. I’m a convert. No notes, lol.
Awesome Desiree! So happy you are enjoying it!
Serving this tomorrow for Thanksgiving and it was the easiest and tastiest homemade Mac n cheese!
My kids are going to love it. Thank you!!
Perfect!
Just another awesome recipe from Sylvia. Best Mac n cheese I’ve ever made and so simple. My family loved it. I let it sit on warm for 30 minutes and the sauce thickened perfectly. Thanks Sylvia, you’re amazing!
So nice to hear this Elan!
We love this and are going to make it for thanksgiving. Has anyone ever doubled this?
Glad you are enjoying! I haven’t doubled it… anyone else?
Do you think it would work okay or best to make it in two batches and then keep it warm?
If you think it will fit in your Instant Pot I bet it would work fine!
Oh wow, this is amazing!! I made mine into a “green chili” Mac and cheese by using up the last jalapeños in the garden (threw them in with the onions). I made this on the stovetop but probably used closer to 5 cups for water, and stirred it like a cacio e Pepe. It has the perfect amount of cheese and is so dreamy (and creamy!) haha thank you for another great one!
Sounds so perfect Angeli!
This tastes exactly like the Kraft Deluxe Macaroni Cheese my mother used to make when we were kids. No more roux and bechamel for me, this was easier and tastier!
Awwww Good! That was the goal here! Glad you enjoyed it. It’s an easy one and a quick win, for sure. 🙂
Can this recipe be done on a stovetop?
I do not have an instant pot.
Thank you.
Yes I think it would taste fine!
Just made the macaroni cheese with tinned milk.Best ever!
Sylvia can you freeze any leftovers?cheerio for now. Able
Hi Able- should freeze just fine!
My pressure cooker worked this time. I had a previous fault and this is delicious many thanks for being an inspiration to cook such great recipes.
Ok – great to hear Claudia~!
I could not get the pressure cooker to work so the recipe did not work at all. would have loved a stove top option
Hummm- shoot. Yes a stove top option is a great idea. I will see what I can do here in the next couple weeks. 😉
You gave one star because you couldn’t make you’re instant pot work? 😂
Thank you, Sylvia, for another tempting recipe. What would the equivalent of “…set the Instant Pot to pressure cook on high for 4 minutes….” be for stove top substitution?
Hi Ame- I would cook the pasta separatly, drain but save a little pasta water, then add pasta to pot with sauteed shallots, adding a little pasta water only if needed. 🙂
An immediate favourite from grown-ups to little ones.
Easy, creamy and flavorsome.
I added bacon bits for my meat eating guests and it was splendid xxxxx
Perfect and happy you liked it!
Hi Sylvia! Wondering if I use gluten free pasta if the cooking time would be the same or different? if so, what do you suggest? Would love to make it for the weekend! thanks! xoxo
You know Gabriela- I’m honestly not sure? Maybe the same? Or perhaps try 1-2 min less? You can continue cooking it on the warm function, but can’t fix it if it is overcooked.
I’ve made this twice and it’s been a big hit in my household; really hits the spot when you’re craving some comfort food. The first time I used fresh mozzarella as the 1C cheese, which I would not recommend. While it tasted good, the consistency was very stringy. The second time I used havarti and the taste and consistency was great. My partner thinks the shallot flavor is too strong (I like it), but next time I may do just a half shallot.
thanks for the feed back Allison- I’ll have to try the Havarti!
Love this. I’m going to borrow the sauce for nachos for NCAA game fun.
Perfect!
Hi Sylvia,I have made this Mac and cheese a couple of times, always delicious, thank you for this easy and oh so tasty recipe.
Awww…thanks so much Carole- I’m very happy you like it!
The original recipe is delicious and very creamy. I added puréed steamed cauliflower and some dry sherry, and then baked it in the oven with breadcrumbs on top.
Yum, sounds great!
Gave it a trial run for Christmas Eve dinner . Yummy !! Is what my kid had to say . It’s a hit .
Thank you for another great recipe.
thanks Cora! Glad you liked it!
An immediate favourite from grown-ups to little ones.
Easy, creamy and flavorsome.
I added bacon bits for my meat eating guests and it was splendid xxxxx
Great to hear!
Thank you for sharing the excellent recipe. I’ll try this recipe.
I don’t have an instant pot but was wondering if this would work in a slow cooker? Has anyone tried?
I haven’t, but don’t see why not? I bet it would work fine!
This was a lighter Mac and cheese than I have done before in the instant pot which we really enjoyed. I did find it a bit salty so next time I won’t add as much. We are looking forward to making this again with gruyere.
thanks Karen- yes you can cut back on the salt and gruyere sounds heavenly!
I made this last night and it was delicious! It was a little soupy and it might be worthwhile to drain some of the water after pressure release before adding additional ingredients. I used kashkaval for my melty cheese and it was super creamy. Very quick relative to other Mac and cheese recipes that rely on roux and bechemel.
Thanks Laura! Yes, it starts off a little watery but if you leave it for any length of time in the instant pot ( or save some as leftovers) it soaks up pretty quickly.
Tried this once with my instant pot(but with reg milk as I dislike the taste of evaporated)–left a cheesy milky mess all over the inside of the lid, so I felt the cleanup of the instant pot was more hassle than making a cheese sauce from scratch to dress pasta. Plus, I like my Mac and cheese with buttered bread oven toasted on top (or a toasted thyme onion bread crumb mix), so I missed the final oven baking to get some crunchy bits. FYI, my son just made a batch with oregano in the cheese sauce plus halved cherry tomatoes for juiciness and a bit of acidity–good additions.
Sorry this didn’t work for you Bri. The Evaporated milk, truly makes this work, and you really can’t taste the flavor once all mixed together. I’m not sure why the lid got messy like that? I totally get missing the crunchy topping.